Showing posts with label Analyst. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Analyst. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Can't negotiate size... and a good thing too

In many companies the Business Analyst or the Project Manager “estimate” the project and bind developers on the project to that estimate. This is an absolutely brutal thing to do to your project. But even within agile teams where the developers estimate, the Business Analysts or Project Managers sometimes tend to challenge and negotiate developer estimates. Not because they don’t trust the developers but merely out of selfishness. Because it gives a tremendous kick to deliver something that a client wants faster.

Now if the team is “estimating” in a “time based” unit such negotiations make some sense. Because a developer might say “Well I’ll take 3 days to do it but developer X is really good at XML so he can probably do it in 2 days”. And that might help given that you can assign the task to developer X (who in all probability is good a everything).

Another way of doing this is for the team to “size” user stories based on relative complexity. Here’s how it works.

As a developer on the team you are only classifying the stories into buckets of high, medium or low complexity. Nothing you can do is going to change the complexity of a given story.

As an analyst or project manager on the team please don’t ask developers questions like “Are you sure this is a 4-pointer?” The only one who can simplify stories is you.

Something Faster is better than Everything Later.
Everything Faster doesn’t exist

Thursday, November 29, 2007

Agile Business Analysts

Yesterday, Craig Brown asked Do we need Agile Business Analysts?. Two and a half years back when I joined ThoughtWorks, I would have said "No, we don't". Today I strongly disagree with the view that Business Analysts can be done away with on Agile projects.

The objective of an Agile project is to provide maximum value to the client as soon as possible.

Now I agree that the ideal situation would be when you have business users & developers who agree and abide by this sentiment. You can happily get rid of the BA in such a situation. Real life, for some reason, is never ideal.

Anyone who has interacted with business users on a medium to large project will have faced situations where it has been hard for the business users to come to a consensus on what they want. Business users are generally representatives of different functions of the organization. Each of them has expectations from the application which more often than not are conflicting. Keeping these users focused on what we set to achieve when we started building the software is what a BA does.

Being on an agile project gives the business users many chances to dream, many chances to make changes. Developers are human too. They dream about technology. While sometimes this can lead to some really cool/unique/usable feature in the product, it can also lead to "overcoolified unnecessities". Now in an ideal situation, all these dreams would come true. Unfortunately, dreams in the real world are bound by budgets & deadlines. Managing these dreams, ideas, changes so as to keep them aligned to the original business objective and deliver most value in the given time and budget is what a BA does.

What agile aims at, is to start minimal and change as required. When a small bug on a story turns out to be a big chunk of enhanced functionality, we create a new story. The tasks mentioned above, along with writing user stories, supporting implementation of the functionality, planning the iterations and releases, testing the developed functionality, etc. together makes for a considerable chunk of work. That's when you create a seperate role called Business Analysts.

Now this role can definitely be performed by developers. In my experience, though, good developers don't really want to do any of this. They want to write good code. That's what they are best at. That's where they will deliver maximum value.

Hence Business Analysts.